How to reply reviewer comments

Author: gjyx

August undefined, 2024

Web7 feb. 2015 · 7. I want to reply to the reviewer's comment (see below) on my paper, My concerns have been addressed satisfactorily and the paper is acceptable. My own reply … Web5 feb. 2024 · Write to the reviewers keeping the Editor in the back of your mind, as at some point he or she might have to adjudicate a difference you have with the reviewers. Make …

How to respond to reviewers’ comments - Earth System …

Web6 aug. 2024 · When you are ready to reply, make a point of thanking the reviewers for the time they have spent reading and assessing your work. Mentioning any comments that you found particularly helpful will show that you appreciate their expertise. 2. Reply to Every Point (Even if You Don’t Agree!) Each point that the reviewers have raised requires a … Web19 jul. 2024 · This stepwise breakdown of writing a rebuttal letter aims to assist authors during the revision to ensure grant of appeal. Step 1: Say Thank You Acknowledge the reviewers time, comments and expertise. Thanking the reviewers sets a positive tone to begin with, providing the basis for an ongoing amicable exchange. chrysler dealership novi

Responding to Manuscript Reviewer and Editor Comments

Web13 apr. 2024 · Author Response File: Author Response.pdf. Reviewer 2 Report · Overall, this is a neat paper with adequate literature review, a qualitatively rich study based on a small sample, well substantiated findings and discussion. The comments that I have are relatively minor and aimed at further enriching the paper. WebIf you're replying to a service review, you can reply directly below the review. If you're replying to a product review, you'll need to click Reply. Type your reply into the reply … Web28 sep. 2015 · In an earlier blog post, we talked about what reviewers can do to provide useful, high-quality reviews. We turn now to some recommendations on how you, as an author, should respond to reviewer comments. Anatomy of a thorough and high-quality response A high-quality response shows the editor that you have thoughtfully … chrysler dealership new smyrna beach fl

Sample Response to Reviewers - American Psychological Association

How to respond to reviewers’ comments - EASE : EASE

WebIf you’re already editing the document ( Edit Document > Edit in Word Web App ), click Review > Show comments. In the Comments pane, click the comment you want to … WebI'd prefer to do 2 reviews for instance and improve by 45%, instead of doing 3 and improving by 50% and spending extra time whereas I can play/practice (probably an inaccurate example, but it's all I can think of ^^,) I'm a Gold IV; Syndra OTP, I think reviewing will benefit me a lot, just not sure how/where to start. Vote. chrysler dealership new port richey flWeb15 aug. 2024 · Encl. Responses to the comments from Reviewer 1, 2, and 3. 给reviewer的response. Reply to Reviewer #1. Dear Reviewers, Thank you very much … descartes intuition and deduction

"Web12 okt. 2024 · Following are 10 simple rules that can help in formulating an effective response to reviewers. Rule 1: Provide an overview, then quote the full set of reviews … " - How to reply reviewer comments

How to reply reviewer comments

WebWe thank the reviewers for their insightful comments and constructive suggestions that have led to the improvement of our paper. Our responses to all the comments and suggestions are detailed below. Reviewer #1: This manuscript proposed an AI framework consisting of hyperparameter selection Web7 apr. 2024 · You can respond to reviews on Yelp in two ways: public comment or direct message. A public comment appears directly below the review you are responding to and can be viewed by anyone who is looking at your Yelp Page. That means your public comment doesn’t just speak to the reviewer, but to all potential customers looking at …

Did you know?

WebCreate an overview of all reviewer comments that you received. For instance in a table. This overview will help both the editor and the reviewers (in case they receive the paper for another round of feedback) to follow your revisions. Acknowledge all requested changes and suggestions, but politely disagree with some. Webthat the expert reviewers’ opinions will provide us guidance to improve the manuscript. A detailed response is provided in the following. In black, we have reported the reviewers’ comments, in red, the detailed replies, and in blue, the sentences that have been changed and/or added in the revised manuscript to address reviewers’ comments.

WebResponse to Editor Comments Dear Prof. Erwin Zehe as handling editor, We greatly appreciate your time dealing with the manuscript and assessing the review comments. The issues raised will be addressed in the revised manuscript and the response letter. We want to briefly outline our responses and changes, firstly in respect to your WebThe reviewers are indicating several concerns with your study design and statistical analysis. Firstly, they are saying that the statistical analysis you have performed is incorrect. This suggests ...

Web27 apr. 2024 · Follow these steps to access the Editor and reviewers' comments: Log in to Editorial Manager for the journal that your manuscript is located. Locate the submission. See How do I find the manuscript I submitted to an Elsevier journal? Click on the section below the corresponds to the folder where you find the submission: View Decision: this ... WebCut and paste reviewer comments into your revision letter, then address them one by one. If you make the requested changes in the manuscript, show the original text of the manuscript, and then your edited text that satisfies the reviewer's comment. Don't be concerned if your revision letter is long; clarity and precision are key with this letter.

Web28 feb. 2024 · You will need to politely point out the contradictory nature of some of the suggestions received (without, we would advise, implying that the editor (s) should have done their job and told you what to do about them, and also without criticising the reviewers), clearly indicating which ones are in opposition to each other.

WebI paste the comments of each reviewer into a file and store these into the appropriate folder. Since I’m an Inbox Zero enthusiast, I also save the decision email into the file. 2. … descargas de windows insider previewWebResponse to reviewers’ comments We are very grateful for the reviews provided by the editors and each of the external reviewers of this manuscript. The comments are … descarga the mandalorianWeb1. Review the manuscript according to the reviewers' comments using the track changes facility in Word. 2. Provide a response to each of the reviewers' comments in a separate Word document. 3. Upload both the revised manuscript and the response to the reviewers' comments. Please acknowledge receipt of this email and let me know if you have any ... chrysler dealership north vancouverWebA structured layout for responding to referees’ comments is suggested that includes the 3 golden rules: (1) respond completely; (2) respond politely; and (3) respond with evidence. How do you write a response to reviewers example? I am/We are grateful to the reviewers for their insightful comments on my paper. chrysler dealership on gratiotWebCyberLeninka. Reading the mind of children in response to food advertising: a cross-sectional study of Malaysian schoolchildren's attitudes towards food and beverages … descarga wassaWebUse the response column to delineate how you addressed the reviewer’s comment, preparing a response for each recommendation. While the bulk of the work will consist … descartes meditations summary 3WebReviewer’s comments: Reviewer #1: This is a review on sugar consumption and health outcomes. The idea is not novel. The ill effects of sugar consumption have been well documented during last couple of decades. This is just a review of reviews. I do not see a real value of this review as the conclusions are on the expected lines. The descartes network